The Secrets to the Best Olive Oil
Tuscany and Italy are known for producing the best olive oils in the world. After all, olive oil is a key component to the Mediterranean diet, and an important part of Italian Cuisine (that was recently named a UNESCO World Heritage). But, why is Italian olive oil so good? Let’s go behind the scenes learning from the olive oil maker and agronomist of Tuscan farm and winery, La Maliosa.
Tuscan Olives
In the rolling hills of Maremma, Tuscany at La Maliosa farm, agronomist and olive oil maker Luigi Antonelli works with La Maliosa’s founder and owner Antonella Manuli to craft extra virgin olive oils that are farmed with the utmost attention to look after the biodiversity of the area. Luigi and Antonella create their oils using 180 historic olive trees, between 80-100 years old, and various cultivars, or types of olives, that are native to Maremma in southwest Tuscany. These plants have survived years of weather related challenges, from deep freezes to droughts, and show the hardiness of these Tuscan cultivars. La Maliosa, as with their wine, farms their olives and tends their groves sustainably, following organic, biodynamic and biodiverse strategies as in the vineyards. Keeping a distance of 36 feet between the olive trees, good exposure and a breezy climate favor a high-quality of extra virgin olive oil, certified organic and vegan, with a high health value, with a high presence of polyphenols, antioxidants and low acidity. La Maliosa’s commitment to their farm and olives is actually a topic we have talked about in length, in our article “Foraging for Tuscany’s Best Olive Oil”.
Agronomist Luigi Antonelli of La Maliosa.
How to Make Good Olive Oil
Just like a good wine, a good olive oil depends on the quality of raw materials. Crafting a delicious and sustainable olive oil, much like crafting a good wine, starts in the fields (and this is not the only similarity between olive oil making and wine making!). Olive plants can take around 5-10 years before their fruit is ready to make oil, but they really reach their prime after 35 years. Olives are pollinated not only by insects transporting pollen from one flower to another, but also via the wind blowing through the groves and sweeping pollen along with it. In fact, Luigi has also introduced different Tuscan cultivars in the La Maliosa groves to create a careful balance for an optimal mix of pollination and production.
Once the olives are ripe, they are hand harvested by spreading a net or sheet under the trees and the olives are picked or knocked down with the sheet catching them as they fall. The nets are used to funnel the olives into crates where selection is then done to separate the largest leaves and branches and pick out the best olives for production. It takes an incredible amount of olives to make oil: one liter of extra virgin olive oil will need almost a half of an olive tree, around 13 pounds, or 8000 olives!
The olives are then crushed or ground to start releasing the natural oils within. Then, the paste created by crushing is loaded into a press to extract the oils. Like in winemaking, there are various levels of crushing and pressing and processes that can take place to extract the oil, some more invasive than others. Lastly, solid impurities are removed from the oil via either a centrifuge or filtering and then it is bottled up, ready for cooking, dunking, or drizzling.
Freshly harvested olives ready to be selected and crushed at La Maliosa.
Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra Virgin means it’s made from pure pressed olives, simply that: harvesting olives and then pressing to make olive oil. It is the most natural fresh-from-the-olive oil you can find. Because there are other types of olive oils, which are a lower grade, other terms have popped up over time, like to say it is “cold pressed” which refers to the temperature range of the olives when crushed.
Needless to say, extra virgin olive oil has not undergone any additional processes or heating outside of the crushing and a light (almost free run) pressing. Extra virgin olive oil, thanks to its minimal processing, retains the most of its healthy benefits and full flavors. It is considered a “perfect” oil, with no flavor flaws and is the oil in its most natural form.
After having made extra virgin olive oil, a producer can decide to reuse the same olives to make more olive oil. In fact, another term to market extra virgin olive oil is to say it is “first run”, meaning that it was made from the first pressing. You can’t call extra virgin olive oil “extra virgin” if it was not made from the first run.
Lower Grades of Olive Oil
After having made extra virgin olive oil, a myriad of processing methods can be applied to make lower grades of olive oil. The olive paste can be pressed harder to extract more oil, the oil becomes “virgin” grade, and finally, with added heat and the highest possible pressing, it descends to “light” or even just plain “olive oil” with no extra labels. This added pressure and heat can change the components of the oil, removing some of the healthy compounds and a lot of the flavors. As the oil is processed more and more it lightens in color, becoming more yellow (like a vegetable or canola oil). After the pressing, the oil can undergo further processing and refining (again, with added heat or even chemicals), and this is labeled as “refined” olive oil.
Keep in mind, all of these methods of refinement cannot be applied to extra virgin olive oil. In fact, La Maliosa does not apply these methods and only makes extra virgin olive oil.
Using Extra Virgin Olive Oil
When selecting an extra virgin olive oil, known as EVOO in foodie circles, pick one in a dark bottle since olive oil is sensitive to direct light and you want it to retain its most natural flavor and healthy benefits. Also, always store your olive oils in a cool cabinet, away from a heat source.
Olives just harvested at La Maliosa’s farm.
Extra virgin olive oil can be used in just about any dish you might dream up in the kitchen, from savory to sweet. Picquant olive oils, like La Maliosa’s Caletra mono cultivar EVOO, are best appreciated raw and natural like in salad dressings or appetizers like pinzimonio to allow their flavors to truly shine. Other extra virgin olive oils, like La Maliosa’s Aurinia blend of four Tuscan cultivars, the abruzzese Febo Extra Virgin Olive Oil, and the Il Nostro Oro from Le Marche, are more buttery and the deliciousness comes through simply dipping fresh bread into them.
La Maliosa’s olive oils, both Caletra and Aurinia are organic extra virgin and first run cold pressed olive oils. They both have many awards, such as Caletra winning an extra gold medal, as best Tuscan organic extra virgin olive oil.
Check our the VeroShop Extra Virgin Olive Oil category to browse all of our EVOOs, and even some Wine + EVOO sets to enjoy the best of both worlds.
Get Some EVOO In Your Pantry
For those of you that know our curation style, you know that we love to support small producers and bring you unique and fun extra virgin olive oils, wines, and specialty foods. And you can enjoy these curations by trying a selection of different wines, foods, and olive oils from our portfolio. We sell to both businesses and consumers across the US:
We are enlarging our network of distributors around the country. Reach out to us if you are interested in distributing our products.
We sell to wine stores and restaurants in certain states - contact us if you would like more info.
We do corporate gifts and sommelier guided wine tastings. Email us and we’ll tailor unique and sustainable corporate gift ideas.
If our farm crafted wines, specialty foods, and olive oils are not in your local shop or restaurant buy wine online hereand we’ll ship it to you, and we ship to most states.
We also have an award winning wine club for true wine explorers seeking to continually discover unique, sustainable and authentic small production wines they never had.
This is a woman made, limited production first cold press organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil from the Maremma hills of Tuscany made from a blend of four Tuscan cultivars. Buttery deliciousness with a bitter kick at the end, thanks to its polyphenols. It has won gold medals in a competition which judges the best extra virgin organic olive oils from around the world.
Farming & Winemaking Highlights: Regenerative Agriculture | Sustainable Farming | Biodynamic | Vegan | No additives | Unfiltered | Organic | Metodo Corino
Fun Facts: The natural farming method that produced this extra virgin olive oil, the metodo corino, is actually patented by La Maliosa woman winemaker Antonella Manuli after she helped to develop it with natural wine legend Lorenzo Corino of Case Corini.
A prestigious first cold press monocultivar organic extra virgin olive oil from the Maremma hils of Tuscany which has won best organic extra virgin olive oil from Tuscany! Its polyphenols which are used to determine how good an olive oil is, are exceptionally high!
Top awards include extra gold, as best Tuscan organic EVOO by Biol Novello which evaluates the best olive oils in the world. In the past this olive oil has also won Best in Italy, as well as Gambero Rosso 3 leaves (their highest rating).
Its aromas of grass, green pepper and mint lead to an intense hot pepper taste and a long finish with black pepper lingering in your mouth. Even just a little drizzled over a simple lettuce salad will bring it to life with flavor.
Farming & Winemaking Highlights: Regenerative Agriculture | Sustainable Farming | Biodynamic | Vegan | No additives | Unfiltered | Organic | Metodo Corino
Fun Facts: The natural farming method that produced this extra virgin olive oil, the metodo corino, is actually patented by La Maliosa woman winemaker Antonella Manuli after she helped to develop it with natural wine legend Lorenzo Corino of Case Corini.
From the hills of Abruzzo near the Adriatic Coast of Italy, comes this Organic EVOO, or Extra Virgin Olive Oil, farmed and made by the Febo family. Farmed sustainably and organic, this natural extra virgin olive oil is also vegan and, like all evoos, a first run - cold press olive oil, the best kind of olive oil for you.
The 2024 harvest is still made from a blend of olives like leccino and 500 year old trees, but now it is mostly the dritta cultivar.
Farming & Winemaking Highlights: Regenerative Agriculture | Sustainable Farming | Biodynamic | Vegan | No additives | Unfiltered | Organic
Fun Facts: The dritta cultivar is a rare one being saved by Davide Febo who is trying to save and rehabilitate it.
This is an olive oil, super food for super foodies. This is small production organic & vegan extra virgin olive oil made primarily from a rare local cultivar from the area of Macerata Italy called Piantone de Mogliano. The buttery flavors and taste of this organic EVOO so inspired the family behind Quercia Scarlatta farm and winery in Le Marche Italy to name it ‘our gold’, or Il Nostro Oro.
Hand harvested and milled at the family’s farm, a first run, cold press evoo, this olive oil’s aromas remind you of stepping into a garden full of fresh green beans with a whiff of black pepper. Likewise, tasting it is like having fresh green beans with black pepper and butter, thanks to its buttery texture. Black pepper continues on the finish.
This organic extra virgin olive oil comes in a 3 liter container, made for following the Mediterranean diet to a tee!
This gift set has the best olive oil around! It is farmed and made by woman owned La Maliosawho farms and crafts organic extra virgin olive oils (and natural wines too) in the wild area of Tuscany, Maremma.
This gift box comes with 2 organic EVOOs:
Aurinia, a buttery and vegetable garden tasting blend of Tuscan cultivars,
and the Monocultivar Caletra organic EVOO which has won best in Tuscan and best in Italy, and is amazing drizzled on veggies, salads and meats.
Use both Italian olive oils to up your cooking game with an added drizzle of flavor.
This set is available with evoos coming in a 250ml size or a larger 500ml size. Great for stocking your pantry or to give as an olive oil gift for that special foodie in your life!
Any add-on to your order has free shipping within the Continental US. If you’re a real foodie, try our other organic EVOOs from other small Italian farms, like this one from Abruzzoand this one from from Le Marche.
Included in this box are:
La Maliosa Aurinia Tuscan Blend Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
La Maliosa Caletra Tuscan Monocultivar Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Farming & Winemaking Highlights: Regenerative Agriculture | Sustainable Farming | Biodynamic | Vegan | No additives | Unfiltered | Organic | Metodo Corino
Fun Facts: The natural farming method that produced this extra virgin olive oil, the metodo corino, is actually patented by La Maliosa woman winemaker Antonella Manuli after she helped to develop it with natural wine legend Lorenzo Corino of Case Corini.
Up your culinary game with delicious & hard-to-find organic extra virgin olive oils from small family run biodynamic farms in Italy. Made with local cultivars and sustainably farmed, these evoos are packed with flavor. This set comes with two 500 ml bottles, one from Abruzzo and one from Le Marche, Italy, great for stocking your pantry or to give as an olive oil gift for that special foodie in your life and for keeping really good olive oil always on hand!
Any add-on to your order has free shipping within the Continental US. If you’re a real foodie, try our other organic EVOOs from a woman-owned small Italian farm La Maliosa, both award winning and high in polyphenols, Aurinia and Caletra.
Included in this box are:
